LoHo wrote:BOAT's learned discourse has led me to a question: his mention that the Mac 26 is a Class B yacht, which I looked up, makes me wonder what the 222's class would be? The ratings originated in 1998, so the 222 was not built with the Class in mind, but....
Okay, right up front - TROLL ALERT! I'm going to tell the story now.
First off, the ce ratings are just stupid things made up by a consortium of manufactures only recently (like 17 years ago?! from a certain place I won't call 'Europe'), to try to dis-credit the United States Coast Guard. It's really baloney when you read what it actually means and also how really LOUSY most European boats actually score on their own stupid scale! That's why I ignore such things. These are based on statistics from insurance companies and guess what? The MORE people on board the MORE likely someone will DIE!
Well, DUH!!! (Did the French go to college to learn that one?)
It's all pretty stupid because if your going to go by statistics - the M boat would carry the highest rating available because NO ONE EVER DIED ON A THE M BOAT! So the whole thing is stupid, but, anyway, since people want to know, here you go:
The ratings were created by non-americans (is that a word? sorry baha, kurz) when (small a) non-americans started making the majority of luxury boats, but ALL boats built after 1998 are rated by the same scale.
The ratings are supposed to be a guarantee of SURVIVABILITY - in other words, in the conditions prescribed the boat is supposed to prevent the loss of life. It does not mean the boat will not lose it's rigging or break a mast - it means that if you have the provisions aboard for the crew compliment they should survive without DYING.
Just to give you an example: There is NO boat manufactured today with a rating that guarantees survivability for the crew in the case of a HURRICANE. You may be surprised to hear that.
Proceeding:
• Category A – Ocean: covers largely self-sufficient boats designed for extended voyages with winds of over Beaufort Force 8 (over 40 knots), and significant wave heights above 13 feet, but excluding abnormal conditions such as hurricanes.
• Category B – Offshore: includes boats operating offshore with winds to 40 knots and significant seas to 13 feet.
• Category C – Inshore: is for boats operating in coastal waters and large bays and lakes with winds to Force 6, up to 27 knots, and significant seas 7 feet high.
• Category D – Inland or sheltered coastal waters: is for boats in small lakes and rivers with winds to Force 4 and significant wave heights to 18 inches.
These ratings also are based on a maximum crew and passenger compliment:
Here are some crew compliment ratings on some very famous boats that all of us think are the best in the industry, yet you may be surprised how fast their ratings downgrade with added crew:
Per Beneteau:
“For example, the Oceanis 60 has been given an A – Ocean – Rating if she has no more than 12 people aboard. But with 13 people aboard, her rating falls to B – Offshore.
Typically, powerboats carry lower ratings, generally starting with B or C ratings. For example the Beneteau Gran Turismo 49 is rated B – Offshore, winds to 40 knots and waves to 13 feet with 14 people aboard. With 16 aboard her classification is lowered to C – Inshore.
Another example is the Beneteau Gran Turismo 35. She has a B rating with 8 people aboard and a C rating with 10 aboard."
Again, Per Beneteau they add this blurb to thier marketing data to try to scare people away from boats made by (small a) "americans":
"Boats sold in the U.S. do not have to be CE rated, but rather, must only meet a few US Coast Guard regulations which address required safety items such as PFDs and flares, carrying capacity for boats under 26’ and level flotation if swamped for boats 20’ and under.”
And this is complete un-adulterated bull$$hit - ALL boats made after 1998 in "america" carry a CE rating. This is just crap the "non-american" manufactures use to scare you away from US made boats. It's pure bull.