MarkSouth wrote:My engine sounds like the same as yours, not sure what the BF in your description is though. mine is a 1998 50 hp 4 stroke.
BF is for Big Foot, which has a larger gearcase and higher reduction ratio (for a larger but slower prop) than the standard 50 hp.
MarkSouth wrote:If I have a 10" pitch now and that is what you have then maybe there is too much "stuff" onboard.
It sounds to me like you still have too much prop. My 50 hp Honda uses a 11-3/4" x 10" pitch 3-blade prop spinning at 2885 rpm at max engine speed of 6000 rpm.
Your prop spins at 3280 rpm at max engine speed of 6000 rpm, and it has a larger diameter prop. That would suggest (suggest, since this isn't an exact science) that you need less pitch than my Honda. The larger prop assumption came from dlandersson's post, where he's using 12-1/2" dia. x 8" pitch, which sounds consistent with the napkin calc above.
Oh, and we still don't know the diameter of your prop. The assumption is also that it's a 3-blade, but it doesn't have to be. I have both 3-blade and 4-blade props for my Honda, and use them depending on the task.