The sea pro, and the big foot seem to have the same lower unit gear ratio (2.33:1).
If you are going to run the engine at a lower rpm, you’ll need more prop pitch for the same speed on the same boat. But since you don’t mention what boat was using a big foot with a 14-10 prop, it’s difficult to extrapolate. Pontoon boat props are typically a good starting point.
Your loading, etc will be different from others. Also, where you try to pick your best performance might be different. For instance, are you trying to get max speed with light loading, or lowest fuel consumption at hull speed?
I’d probably start with the 14:11. I ran a selection using around 4,000 lb boat and crew, and overall performance, and got both 14-10 and 14-11 selections.
See this spot for one approach to picking the prop.
https://www.mercurymarine.com/en/us/pro ... !/step-one